revdorothyl: keswindhover made this (Belief)
Add MemoryShare This Entry
posted by [personal profile] revdorothyl at 07:07pm on 05/08/2006 under
Honestly, I have to say that this was perhaps the first M. Night Shyamalan movie that I not only admired but also had a lot of FUN watching. (I should note here that I never got around to seeing "Signs", so I'm comparing "Lady in the Water" only to the likes of "The Sixth Sense", the very provocative and unsettling but emotionally resonant "Unbreakable", and "The Village", which was useful for starting discussions but not ultimately satisfying to me personally as a story or as a movie-going experience.)

I'm short of time tonight, but I felt so jazzed Thursday afternoon, after seeing "Lady in the Water" for the first time that I felt I just had to stay all the way to the final dedication at the end of the credits.

Now, I need more time to figure out exactly why I found this film so encouraging and inspiring.

Maybe, it was because of that whole "nobody knows who they really are" thing (although, honestly, who WOULDN'T have guessed that it was the cereal-box-synchronicity-reading kid, rather than the puzzle-solving dad, who was the real symbolist/interpreter, from our first meeting with that family? But, still, that only means that I knew who the kid was, not that the kid himself knew who he was, so I guess the principle remains true.)

Or, maybe it was seeing how this oddball community came together -- no matter how long it took to sort out exactly who was who -- to try to do one good, meaningful thing for one another and for the world. Shades of what we all love best about the "chosen families" in our favorite shows, from BtVS to Farscape, as discussed in that Friday morning WriterCon panel a couple of weeks ago.

Or maybe I just identified heavily with the custodian who turns out to be so much more, who had lost so much and suffered so much, but still wouldn't give up hope for the world, wouldn't give up trying to take care of people, even if he no longer felt able to do so as a doctor. And maybe I identified even more heavily with Shyamalan's character himself, "the vessel" who had to overcome all his fears and finish his work . . . and then come to terms with the fact that his contribution to the world would require his own death at an early age.

Or maybe I just enjoyed all those quirky, weird, wounded people pooling their talents and "knowledge" to try to save the world, or at least the life of one little "narf".

At any rate, I felt strong enough afterwards -- having been feeling overwhelmed with health concerns and a general sense of the unrelenting stresses of life prior to going to the movie -- to go run some errands, including voting in the primary election. And then Friday morning, I took the risk of taking advantage of Tennessee's back-to-school tax holiday to go to a different store and buy myself the laptop computer that I had really wanted, all along. Fortunately, I was able to return the unopened boxes containing the big desk-top set-up that I'd purchased on Tuesday and had been unwilling to even look at since then.

Not much of an achievement, I know, but with the way I'd been feeling earlier in the week, finding the wherewithal to go back to the stores and say "this is what I really want", and "No matter how nice the sales guy was, I'm not going to keep the stuff I never wanted" does feel like a victory, no matter how small.

Then, I went to my doctor's appointment at the health center yesterday afternoon, where the new doctor (my regular doc wasn't on duty that day) took blood samples but assured me that no, the creeping numbness in my extremities that had been spreading from right to left and up my limbs since Sunday, WASN'T likely to be either leprosy (too fast and no rash) or a stroke (too evenly balanced on both sides of my body), and took blood samples to try and find out what WAS wrong. Numbness is no worse today, by the way, than it was when I awoke yesterday, so all in all, life does not suck.

Oh, and my sister was very encouraging when I talked to her last night: even after I told her that I'd been planning to leave her my new laptop computer in my will, but that apparently I'm not actually dying yet, she still said how glad she was that I wasn't dying! Sometimes, it's very good to have a sister -- especially one who's willing to talk nonsense to you on the phone for an hour, when you've been scaring yourself silly all week with thoughts of strange, arcane illnesses that surely only Gregory House could diagnose!
There are 10 comments on this entry. (Reply.)
rahirah: (Default)
posted by [personal profile] rahirah at 12:29am on 06/08/2006
Hm, I may have to see this--I've been edgy about his films ever since Signs, which really, really annoyed the heck out of me when the aliens turned out to come from the planet of Moronia in the Really Stupid Galaxy...
 
posted by [identity profile] revdorothyl.livejournal.com at 01:21am on 06/08/2006
Actually, I should've said that "Signs" is the only one of his films that I've NEVER seen, so I can't respond to that (however, the fact that I found the way it was marketed off-putting enough to never, ever get around to seeing it, all these years later, probably does mean something). I need to amend that post to read "compared to "Sixth Sense," "Unbreakable", and "The Village".

But yes, I think you might have fun watching this. There are some incredibly stupid people, at times, but only in the way that sometimes people are incredibly dense, at times (though they smarten up and step up to the plate when most needed, for the most part). However, if you remember that the whole thing is set up around a myth that's told as a bedtime story, then I think you'll get the spirit of it.

So, I gather you think I should continue to give "Signs" a miss?
rahirah: (Default)
posted by [personal profile] rahirah at 01:41am on 06/08/2006
Well... a lot of people loved it. And the first part is excellent. My dislike stems from two things: One, the aliens are colossally stupid. Two, I think he fatally undermined the point he was trying to make about faith by having the aliens be incontrovertably real.
 
posted by [identity profile] texanfan.livejournal.com at 02:42am on 06/08/2006
For me the problem with Signs was largely a matter of editing. There were scenes that went on until they'd drained any point there might have been right out of them. Your thoughts on The Village mirror mine precisely.

After our disappointment with The Village we were debating seeing Lady in the Water. With your high recommendation I believe we'll try to see it. :)

Very scary medical stuff! Did I miss a post about this? My prayers are with you and your doctors as they try to diagnose you.
 
posted by [identity profile] revdorothyl.livejournal.com at 02:56am on 06/08/2006
No, you didn't miss a post. I hadn't mentioned the numbness until now. I guess I kept hoping that it would go away, but by the middle of the week it became clear that it wasn't going to, not anytime soon.

Two years ago and a bit (around late March/early April of 2004) I had a different sort of numbness in my extremities that turned out to be a severe calcium deficiency. Apparently, I'd always had something called pseudohypoparathyroidism, they eventually decided, but I'd been able to take in enough calcium and vitamin D to avoid being symptomatic . . . until I was hospitalized for severe asthma for the second time that year, meaning I'd gotten more prednizone in the past six months than ever before, and possibly that had messed up the amount of vitamin D and calcium in my system. Anyways, a few weeks after getting out of the hospital for asthma, I was going numb for no apparent reason. And ever since then I've been taking hefty calcium and vitamin D supplements, just to keep up with what my system naturally leaks or somehow loses.

Hopefully, this will turn out to be just a variation on that, possibly due to my changing calcium supplements a week ago.

Meanwhile, all prayers gratefully accepted. Thanks, friend!
 
posted by [identity profile] texanfan.livejournal.com at 03:03am on 06/08/2006
Glad to know you've got a pretty good handle on what it is, and even more so that it's something manageable. Take very good care of yourself.
 
posted by [identity profile] maeve-rigan.livejournal.com at 03:34am on 06/08/2006
Glad to hear you liked Lady in the Water, and for some of the same reasons I did. I went to see it in spite of having read way too many negative reviews, some by critics I respected, and I was glad I did.
 
posted by [identity profile] revdorothyl.livejournal.com at 12:16am on 07/08/2006
I hadn't heard or read any reviews, but I DID hear a phone-in show/interview with Shyamalan on NPR the day before the film opened, and between that and his appearance on "The Daily Show" on Comedy Central, I figured this guy was a lot more FUN than people have wanted to believe, and had hopes that this movie might be fun, as well. Which it sure was. Glad you liked it, too!
 
posted by [identity profile] x-h00ine.livejournal.com at 05:59am on 06/08/2006
(a) Yay you! (b) I, too, liked Lady in the Water a lot. Anthro-leaning geeks unite! I think I'd place it alongside Unbreakable as my favorite. I honestly don't get the fashionability of the Shyamalan hate. I think the New York Times reviewer was on to something in saying that Shyamalan was hailed as an auteur when he should have merely been considered "promising," although I think that the review ends up drawing the wrong conclusions from it (I think the flaw is at least as much in the sharklike tendencies of media and the public as it is in Shyamalan).

I hope you continue to get good communication on your health and you get the recent badness well and truly licked, soon.
 
posted by [identity profile] revdorothyl.livejournal.com at 12:14am on 07/08/2006
Yes! "Unbreakable" used to be my unquestioned favorite, but I laughed a WHOLE lot more during "Lady in the Water" and certainly left it feeling happier! I loved the way that Shyamalan himself seemed to be pointing out that critics only THINK they know the score in this film (I made extensive use in my sermon this morning of the negative example of what happens when you INSIST that you know what story you're in and what role you're playing, and ignore the gentle "hints" that the universe gives you that you might be wrong -- at least, that's what I got from that scary/humorous encounter between the critic and the creature in the basement, as well as how wrong he was about so many other things). Yay! him, for not letting all the hype keep him from telling his bedtime story the way HE wanted to tell it.

And thanks for the good health wishes. Still no worse, at least, so I'm hopeful.

October

SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
1
 
2
 
3
 
4
 
5
 
6
 
7
 
8
 
9
 
10
 
11
 
12
 
13
 
14
 
15
 
16
 
17 18
 
19
 
20
 
21
 
22
 
23
 
24
 
25
 
26
 
27
 
28
 
29
 
30
 
31